ETEP lights

ARTICLES

Debriefing a flight with your instructor: what the aircraft's log shows

After a training flight, the student remembers the stress, the instructor remembers what they said, and neither remembers the airspeed at the flare. The log the avionics writes on every flight, or the track of a phone, replaces those recollections with a timeline. What it shows, what it does not, and how to use it without turning it into a trial.

All articles·Published ·6 min read

Why memory is a poor debriefing tool

A training flight lasts an hour; the debrief is about the three minutes that did not go to plan: the flare, the go-around, the simulated engine failure. By the time the aircraft is put away, each keeps their own version, and the student can leave convinced of something that did not happen.

Replaying the flight changes the conversation. Stop the picture on short final: here is the airspeed, the rate of descent, the bank angle, the track against the centreline. The discussion moves from who remembers better to what the aircraft actually did. A point that took ten minutes on a whiteboard is shown in thirty seconds, and the student sees for themselves the deviation they were told about in flight.

The data is often already there

Many glass-cockpit trainers record every flight without being asked. Garmin G1000, G3000 or G3X avionics writes a log to the SD card in its display; other panels and engine monitors do the same. The file holds position, altitudes, speeds and, depending on the installation, attitude and engine parameters. It often stays on the card, unread.

An aircraft with analogue instruments writes nothing. A GPS track then covers many exercises: the track of a phone, a navigation app or a portable GPS gives the path, the ground speed and the GPS altitude. Enough to replay a circuit, a navigation exercise or an approach path; not the airspeed nor the attitude.

InformationAvionics logGPS track (phone, tablet)
Path, ground speedYesYes
AltitudePressure altitude and GPS altitudeGPS altitude only
AirspeedYesNo
Attitude, bankDepending on the avionicsNo
Engine parametersIf an engine monitor is connectedNo
Video, audioNoOnly if the phone films

What the log lets you review

  • The approach: the airspeed, the rate of descent and the bank angle between the stabilisation height and the threshold; the criteria are set out in our article on the stabilised approach.
  • The flare and the touchdown: the rate of descent and the load factor at touchdown, the airspeed, the distance rolled before stopping.
  • Turns: the bank angle and load factor of a steep turn, the altitude held.
  • Engine management: temperatures and speeds, when the log holds them.
  • Navigation: the route flown, the altitudes, the time over the turning points.

The thresholds software applies to flag an approach or a landing are settings, not the aircraft's limits: the flight manual and the instructor decide what is acceptable.

What it does not show

  • What the student was looking at, their hands, the view outside: only a camera shows that.
  • What was said on board: the audio is not in the log.
  • Intentions: why the student went around, what the instructor had asked for.
  • Airspeed and attitude, when the aircraft has no glass cockpit.
  • Precision it does not have: a GPS altitude less reliable than the altimeter, a track that drops out under the canopy.

So the replay supports what the instructor says; it does not replace it. A school that wants video, audio and parameters on one time base, and a recording that survives an accident, fits a recorder on board: that is the subject of our article Debriefing flight training, on etep.com.

Running the session

  1. Debrief while the flight is fresh: the same day, with the log collected back at the parking spot.
  2. Let the student speak first: what they take from the flight, what they would do differently. The replay then confirms or corrects.
  3. Go straight to the event: find it in the parameters (the lowest airspeed on final, the load factor at touchdown) rather than scrolling through the cruise.
  4. Stop the picture and have it described: where the aircraft was, at what speed, what should have been done.
  5. Keep the same views from one lesson to the next, to compare and show progress.
  6. End on one point to work on next flight, written in the progress record.

Afterwards, the student can go over the flight alone, at their own pace: that is where a good share of the learning happens.

Who sees the flights

The surest way to ruin a debrief is to use it to sanction. A student who fears their recorded flights will be held against them flies to avoid blame rather than to learn: tense, they stop trying anything, and that is when they stop making progress.

Set the rules before the first flight: the flights belong to the student; they open them to the instructors of their choice; they serve training, and other uses only in cases agreed in advance. To follow a club's safety, figures without names, by aircraft and by runway, are worth more than a ranking of pilots.